Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Cabins for Rent in New Buffalo, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Walking Distance To Beach And Shops |
8.7 / 10 (42 Reviews) |
From 347$ | |
| Anchors Away Villa |
7.3 / 10 (11 Reviews) |
From 221$ | |
| Eagles Beach Nest II |
9.5 / 10 (15 Reviews) |
From 954$ | |
| The Pelton House Villa |
9.0 / 10 (1 Reviews) |
From 276$ | |
| Great Escape Villa |
10.0 / 10 (2 Reviews) |
From 248$ |
When you think of escaping the hustle and bustle of everyday life, there's something undeniably enchanting about rustic cabins that beckon a return to nature. My journey to New Buffalo was nothing short of transformative, where the allure of cozy accommodations intertwined beautifully with the serene natural surroundings. Nestled among tall pines and rolling hills, these charming retreats offer the perfect backdrop for a gathering with friends, where laughter dances through the air and memories are crafted by the lake.
As the golden sun casts a warm glow over the landscape, stepping into one of these snug cabins feels like stumbling upon a hidden sanctuary. Imagine sipping your morning coffee on a rustic porch, enveloped by the soothing sounds of rustling leaves and chirping birds. Each cabin tells a story of its own, adorned with wooden accents and charming décor that create an inviting atmosphere for groups seeking an escape. Here, even the simplest moments, like gathering around a fire pit under a blanket of stars, become cherished experiences that linger long after the trip ends.
The beauty of this destination lies not only in its serene accommodations but also in the endless adventures that await just beyond the front door. From exploring scenic trails to indulging in local delights, there's an element of magic in every corner of New Buffalo. With friends by your side, sharing old tales and creating new ones, each experience becomes a cherished gem tucked away in the scrapbook of your mind. The connection you forge here—both with your companions and the magnificent landscape—invites you to return time and again.
Whether you’re planning a weekend retreat or an extended getaway, the charm of these rustic cabins continues to draw travelers looking for both adventure and relaxation. From cozy evenings spent playing board games to sun-soaked days filled with laughter and exploration, this majestic area offers the ideal canvas for creating unforgettable memories. Embrace the call of nature, gather your closest friends, and discover the magic that awaits in the heart of New Buffalo's woodlands.
Best New Buffalo Cabins for Rent
View all photos
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops
From 347$
Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina is approximately 5 minutes' drive away. The centre of New Buffalo is a 10-minute walk away. American cuisine is served at New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq and The Stray Dog Bar & Grill, which are 50 metres away from the villa.
In proximity to this venue you'll find Barney's.
They have a fully equipped kitchen with facilities, and offer a tub and a shower in the bathroom. The accommodation has 1 bathroom.
View all photos
Anchors Away Villa
From 221$
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 2 km from the venue. It takes a 5-minute drive from the accommodation to Barney's and getting to South Bend Regional airport will take around 56 minutes by car.
You can get to Galien River County Nature Park in a few minutes by car.
A bathroom comprises a tub and a shower.
View all photos
Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard
The property is 5 minutes' drive from Barney's. The centre of New Buffalo is approximately 15 minutes’ walk away. You can taste American cuisine in I CAN Cafe, located 7 minutes' stroll from Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard.
You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
Most rooms overlook the garden.
Luxury Cabins in New Buffalo
Nestled amidst the serene landscapes of New Buffalo, the luxury cabins invite you and your friends to experience a perfect blend of comfort and nature. Imagine gathering around a crackling fire pit under a starry sky, sharing stories and laughter as the evening unfolds, surrounded by rustic charm and modern elegance. Each cabin boasts spacious living areas that encourage late-night games and heartfelt conversations, while expansive windows frame breathtaking views of lush greenery or tranquil waters. Whether it’s the warmth of a wood-burning stove or the thrill of exploring nearby trails, these cabins create a cozy oasis where memories are made, laughter echoes, and friendships deepen in an enchanting escape from the everyday hustle and bustle.
View all photos
Eagles Beach Nest II
From 954$
The accommodation is 5 minutes' drive from Whittaker Woods Golf Course. The centre of New Buffalo is at 1 km. Promeny Olive & Wine and Rios Mexican Food offering both food and drinks are 300 metres away.
Points of interest near the villa include Saint Mary of the Lake Church as well as the full - service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina.
View all photos
Marquette Cottage
Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina lies within a 16-minute walk of the property. Your meals can be enjoyed in the barbecue New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq a few steps away.
You can get to Galien River County Nature Park in a few minutes by car.
Marquette Cottage has 0 bedrooms.
Beach facilities include free Wi-Fi.
View all photos
The Pelton House Villa
From 276$
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 2 km from the accommodation. Guests will appreciate the nearby Redamak's.
You can get to New Buffalo Railroad Museum in a few minutes by car.
A bathroom comprises a tub and a shower.
Cheap Cabins for Rent in New Buffalo
Imagine gathering your closest friends for an unforgettable getaway, nestled in a charming cabin in New Buffalo. Picture evenings spent laughing around a crackling fire pit, with the scent of s'mores sweetening the air, and days filled with adventures exploring nature's beauty just outside your door. These affordable cabins offer the perfect backdrop for making memories, with cozy nooks to unwind and spacious common areas for sharing stories long into the night. Whether it's a spontaneous retreat or a well-planned celebration, these cabins create the ideal setting for friendship and fun—a true escape from the everyday hustle, where bonds are strengthened and the joys of togetherness are celebrated.
View all photos
Great Escape Villa
From 248$
The villa is 5 minutes' drive from First United Methodist. The centre of New Buffalo is 2 km away.
You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
This property also comes with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms which provide guests with a bath and a shower.
The venue has a dining table on its balcony.
View all photos
Deer Haus Villa
Four Winds Casino lies within a 25-minute walk of the villa. The centre of New Buffalo is at 2 km.
You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car.
Deer Haus Villa comprises 0 bedrooms.
View all photos
Lake Michigan Family Beach House
Barney's is approximately 5 minutes' drive away. The centre of New Buffalo can be reached within a 30-minute walk.
You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
The views of lake are featured in certain rooms.
Pet Friendly Cabins in New Buffalo
Nestled amidst the serene landscapes of New Buffalo, the pet-friendly cabins offer an inviting retreat for those who believe that no adventure should be left behind without their four-legged friends. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, the morning sunlight filtering through the trees, while your beloved pet joyfully explores the surrounding scenery. These cozy cabins provide the perfect backdrop for unforgettable moments with your pals—be it s'mores around a fire pit, playful hikes along scenic trails, or lazy afternoons spent lounging on the porch with your furry companions by your side. It’s an opportunity to reconnect with nature and create lasting memories, all while ensuring that every member of your party, including the four-legged ones, feels right at home.
View all photos
Merchant Street Retreat
From 649$
Local attractions include Barney's steps away from the villa and city centre 1 km away. A 13-minute walk will lead you to Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. The barbecue at 550 metres from the property specialises in American cuisine.
Merchant Street Retreat Villa offers accommodation with direct access to New Buffalo Township Library.
This venue also has a fully equipped kitchen and 2 bathrooms.
A private pool is located on-site.
View all photos
Eagle'S Beach Nest
From 539$
The venue is set 10 minutes by car from Galien River County Nature Park and 1.1 km from Barney's. The centre of New Buffalo is 1 km from this villa. Guests can try Mexican meals in the quick bites Rios Mexican Food located 250 metres away.
You can get to Whittaker Woods Golf Course in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Surf'S Up Villa
From 428$
Local attractions include Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina steps away from the property and city centre 1 km away. It is a 55-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport and a 5-minute drive to New Buffalo Railroad Museum.
You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
A tub and a shower are also available.
Surf'S Up Villa features a patio for guests' comfort.
Secluded Cabin Rentals in New Buffalo
Picture yourself and your closest friends escaping to a serene retreat in the heart of nature, surrounded by the whispering breeze and the melodies of chirping birds. These secluded cabin rentals offer the perfect backdrop for unforgettable adventures, where laughter echoes through the tall pines and late-night storytelling by the firekindles camaraderie. Imagine cozy evenings spent roasting marshmallows, sharing secrets, and stargazing under a blanket of twinkling stars. With spacious interiors that invite togetherness and outdoor spaces that beckon exploration, these cabins provide an idyllic setting for playful days of hiking or simply lounging on the porch with a good book. Whether you're planning a weekend getaway or a longer stay, the magic of friendship comes alive in a space that feels like your very own sanctuary.
View all photos
Apple Blossom Resort By Dwell Vacations
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 3 km from the venue. If you feel like visiting the surroundings, check out New Buffalo Railroad Museum 3.5 km away.
You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car.
One can enjoy a private swimming pool on-site.
View all photos
The Tulip Tree House Villa
From 155$
Ambler Flatwoods Nature Preserve is approximately 10 minutes' drive away.
You can get to New Buffalo Railroad Museum in a few minutes by car.
A bath and a shower are also offered for free in the bathroom.
View all photos
Beachcomber
From 373$
Local attractions include Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina steps away from the villa and city centre 1 km away. It is a 53-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport and a 5-minute drive to New Buffalo Railroad Museum. The quick bites Rios Mexican Food can be reached after a 5-minute walk.
You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car.
A tub and a shower are also available.
Honeymoon Cabins in New Buffalo
Nestled amidst the serene beauty of the landscape, these charming honeymoon cabins invite couples to escape into a world of romance and tranquility. Each cabin exudes a cozy, rustic charm, perfect for unwinding after a day of adventures or simply basking in each other’s company. With crackling fireplaces and private porches overlooking picturesque views, they provide an intimate ambiance that sets the stage for whispered dreams and shared laughter. The surrounding nature beckons lovers to embark on sunset strolls or enjoy quiet moments together, forging memories that will linger long after the trip has ended. Here, within the embrace of the wilderness, couples can truly connect with one another, making it the ideal backdrop for their romantic getaway.
View all photos
Hydrangea House Villa
From 500$
Local attractions include Barney's steps away from the villa and city centre 1 km away. The full - service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina is 1.1 km away and South Bend Regional airport is 55 km from the property. Quench your thirst with your favourite drink at the dessert restaurant Oink's Dutch Treat within 6 minutes' walk from Hydrangea House Villa.
Warner Vineyards Tasting Room is just steps away.
Romantic Cabin Rentals in New Buffalo
Nestled amidst the serene beauty of the woods, these romantic cabin rentals in New Buffalo offer the perfect escape for couples seeking an intimate retreat. Each cabin, adorned with rustic charm and thoughtful touches, creates a cozy ambiance that beckons you to unwind and reconnect. Imagine sipping morning coffee on a private porch, the sounds of nature enveloping you, or sharing a candlelit dinner by a crackling fire. With nearby trails for hiking and the soothing waters of the lake just a stone's throw away, these cabins provide a perfect blend of adventure and tranquility, allowing love to blossom amidst the breathtaking scenery. Whether it’s stargazing from a hot tub or cuddling up with a good book in an inviting nook, these rentals create an unforgettable backdrop for romance and rejuvenation.
Cabins for Rent in New Buffalo with Hot Tub
Imagine a cozy retreat where the laughter of friends fills the air, and the soothing sounds of nature envelop you in a tranquil embrace. Picture a cabin designed for bonding, complete with a hot tub where the warmth of the bubbling water invites long chats under starlit skies or spontaneous cannonballs from fellow adventure-seekers. With open spaces to gather and share meals, recline by the fire, and swap stories, this haven becomes a canvas for unforgettable memories. Whether it's an impromptu game night or exploring nearby trails during the day, every corner of this rustic sanctuary is crafted for connection, ensuring that every moment spent together feels like a treasured adventure.
New Buffalo Cabin Rentals with Pool
Imagine gathering your closest friends for a sun-soaked retreat at a charming cabin, where laughter dances through the trees as you unwind by the shimmering pool. Surrounded by nature’s embrace, the cozy interiors invite late-night conversations and shared meals, while the expansive outdoor space beckons for fun-filled afternoons. The thrill of splashing in the refreshing water, coupled with the joy of roasting marshmallows over a crackling fire, creates a perfect backdrop for unforgettable memories. Whether it’s lounging poolside or exploring nearby trails, each moment spent in this warm, inviting haven connects you and your friends in a tapestry of adventure and camaraderie, promising a getaway that will be cherished long after the trip ends.